Brother denies using firmware updates to brick printers with third-party

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Avoid to content

3-year-old Reddit post triggers outcry

Sibling: Updates aren’t behind deterioration of quality or elimination of functions.

A Brother MFCL3750CDW printer.

Credit: Brother

Sibling printer are popular suggestions for individuals looking for a printer with none of the rubbish. By rubbish, we suggest printers all of a sudden bricking functions, like scanning or printing, if users set up third-party cartridges. Some printer companies outright obstruct third-party toner and ink, in spite of client blowback and claims. Sibling’s printer have actually traditionally worked fine with non-Brother devices. A YouTube video published today, however, along with older social networks posts, declare that Brother has actually gone to the dark side and deteriorated printer performance with third-party cartridges. Sibling informs Ars that this isn’t real.

On March 3, YouTuber Louis Rossman published a video stating that “Brother turns heel & & ends up being anti-consumer printer business.” The video, identified by Tom’s Hardware, has 163,000 deem of this writing and appears to be based upon a Reddit post from 2022. Because post, Reddit user 20Factorial stated that firmware upgrade W1.56 triggered the automated color registration function to quit working on his Brother MFC-3750 when utilizing third-party cartridges.

“With the colors unable to be lined up, the printer is efficiently non-functional,” 20Factorial stated. The Redditor went on to state that when asked, a Brother customer care representative verified that “the printer is non-functional without real toner.”

Rossman developed a Wiki page breaking down the reported problems, consisting of “printers continue to work with third-party toner however print at abject quality unless OEM toner is set up.” He likewise kept in mind that Brother printers immediately upgrade when linked to the Internet which Brother does not use older firmware variations to users.

Table of Contents

Sibling’s reaction

Bro rejected to Ars Technica that it purposefully bricks printer performance when users set up third-party toner or ink. In a declaration, the business stated:

We understand the current incorrect claims recommending that a Brother firmware upgrade might have limited using third-party ink cartridges. Please be ensured that Brother firmware updates do not obstruct using third-party ink in our makers.

Sibling stated it’s “actively resolving the source of these incorrect claims to guarantee precise details is readily available to our consumers.”

20Factorial isn’t the only one who has actually declared to see printer abilities decrease when attempting to utilize a third-party cartridge. A month back, Reddit user West-Skin4092 declared:

I had a mistake message when I set up a non[-]OE toner on a 3770[,] and I took the initial chip off the Brother cartridge and switched it onto the non-OE toner cartridge[,] and it acknowledged it and works.

Reddit user Gloomy-Score-8279 declared to have a comparable experience with their MFC-L3750CDW however included that the workaround of putting a Brother chip on a non-Brother cartridge quit working after an undefined upgrade.

2 years earlier, fncamo declared on Reddit that their MFC-L3370CDW stopped printing and scanning when attempting to utilize third-party toner after setting up brand-new firmware.

When requested more information, Brother informed Ars that “firmware updates do not obstruct using third-party compatibles,” however included:

Bro printers do not purposefully deteriorate print quality based upon whether a Brother Genuine or non-genuine ink/ toner cartridge is utilized. Bro can not validate the quality of printing that will result when utilizing a third-party suitable with a Brother printer.

When asked where Brother believes the confusion might be originating from, the business stated:

Sibling motivates using Brother Genuine ink and toner for ideal efficiency and dependability, and it is basic practice that we carry out a Brother [G]enuine check when repairing a Brother printer. Suitable products might vary in quality, and in order to validate that a printer is working appropriately, we like to fix with Brother Genuine materials. Our company believe this check in the procedure might have caused a misconception[,] As we verified, the firmware upgrade would not be accountable for the destruction of quality or elimination of printer functions.

Oh, sibling

With the majority of claims of bricked Brother printers originating from individuals online, it’s difficult to verify the precision of the reports and whether user mistake or the picked cartridges are aspects.

It would be stunning for a business like Brother, which has actually gone far for itself as a reputable, more consumer-friendly printer business than competitors, to blatantly lie about this. On the other hand, with the print market decreasing and measures up to more greatly depending on ink and services to survive, there is reward for Brother to press individuals to exclusive cartridges. After seeing the reaction that other printer companies withstood for bricking printers through firmware updates, Brother would be showing horrible judgement by not being in advance about breaking its consumers’ residential or commercial property.

Significantly, Brother’s declarations to Ars leave the door open for third-party cartridges to work badly with Brother gadgets, however without more concrete proof, we can’t with confidence state that Brother lags the reported user problems.

For what it’s worth, an Ars staffer has actually been effectively utilizing their Brother HL-2270DW printer with v4ink-brand toner, however their gadget does not get automated updates. We’ll let you understand if we discover additional proof of Brother breaking printers. In the meantime, we would not blame you for making sure more control over your printer by disabling automated updates.

Scharon is a Senior Technology Reporter at Ars Technica composing news, evaluations, and analysis on customer gizmos and services. She’s been reporting on innovation for over 10 years, with bylines at Tom’s Hardware, Channelnomics, and CRN UK.

190 Comments