As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
(Image credit: Pakawat Thongcharoen/Getty Images)
Researchers might have simply fallen a 100-year-old theory about what holds up the greatest range of mountains in the world, brand-new research study programs.
The Himalayan mountains formed in the accident in between the Asian and Indian continents around 50 million years earlier, when tectonic forces squeezed Tibet so hard that the area crumpled and its location diminished by nearly 620 miles( 1,000 kilometers ). The Indian tectonic plate ultimately slipped under the Eurasian plate, doubling the density of Earth’s crust underneath the Himalayas and Tibetan Plateau to the north, and adding to their uplift.
For a century, the dominating theory has actually been that this doubling of the crust alone brings the weight of the Himalayas and the Tibetan Plateau. Research study released in 1924 by Swiss geologist Émile Argand reveals the Indian and Asian crusts stacked on top of each other, together extending 45 to 50 miles (70 to 80 km) deep underneath Earth’s surface area.This theory does not stand up to analysis, scientists now state, due to the fact that the rocks in the crust turn molten around 25 miles (40 km) deep due to severe temperature levels.
“If you’ve got 70 km of crust, then the lowermost part becomes ductile… it becomes like yogurt — and you can’t build a mountain on top of yogurt,” Pietro Sternaian associate teacher of geophysics at the University of Milano-Bicocca in Italy and the lead author of a brand-new research study examining the geology underneath the Himalayas, informed Live Science.
Proof has actually long recommended that Arnand’s theory is incorrect, however the concept of 2 nicely stacked crusts is so enticing that many geologists have not questioned it, Sternai stated. Historically, “any data that would come along would be interpreted in terms of a single, double-thickness crustal layer,” he stated.
Related: Will Mount Everest constantly be the world’s highest mountain?
Get the world’s most interesting discoveries provided directly to your inbox.
The brand-new research study exposes there is a piece of mantle sandwiched in between the Asian and Indian crusts. This describes why the Himalayas grew so high, and how they still stay so high today, the authors composed in the paper, released Aug. 26 in the journal Tectonics
The mantle is the layer of Earth that sits straight underneath the crust. It is much denser than the crust and, for that reason, does not melt at the exact same temperature levels. The crust is so light and resilient that it acts likewise to an iceberg, raising up greater above Earth’s surface area the thicker it gets.
Sternai and his associates found the mantle insert by mimicing the accident in between the Asian and Indian continents on a computer system. The design revealed that as the Indian plate slipped underneath the Eurasian plate and began to liquify, blobs of it increased and connected themselves not to the bottom of the Asian crust, however to the base of the lithosphere, which is the stiff external layer of the world made up of the crust and upper mantle.
A diagram from the research study demonstrates how blobs of the Indian crust increased and connected to the bottom of the lithosphere after the Asian and Indian continents clashed. In dark blue we see the upper mantle, and in orange, the partly molten Indian crust. (Image credit: Sternai et al. 2025, Tectonics. Rearranged under Creative Commons licence CC BY 4.0.)This is basic, Sternai stated, due to the fact that it suggests there is a stiff layer of mantle in between the stacked crusts strengthening the entire structure underneath the Himalayas. The 2 crusts offer adequate buoyancy to keep the area raised, while the mantle product supplies resistance and mechanical strength. “You’ve got all the ingredients you need to uplift topography and sustain the weight of the Himalayas and Tibetan plateau,” he stated.
The scientists then compared their outcomes with seismic information and details collected straight from rocks. The mantle sandwich in the simulation matched previous proof that Arnand’s theory could not discuss, study co-author Simone Piliaan assistant teacher of geoscience at King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals in Saudi Arabia, informed Live Science.
“Things actually start to make sense now,” Pilia stated. “Observations that seemed to be enigmatic are actually now more easily explained by having a model where you have crust, mantle, crust.”
The research study provides strong proof for this design, however opposing Arnaud’s 100-year-old theory is questionable due to the fact that it has actually been so extensively embraced, Pilia stated.
“I think the authors are correct that this is controversial,” Adam Smitha postdoctoral research study partner in mathematical modeling at the University of Glasgow in Scotland who was not associated with the research study, informed Live Science in an e-mail. “All prior work generally agreed that all the material beneath the Himalayas came from the crust.”
The outcomes are still possible, and they discuss a number of geological curiosity in the Himalayas, Smith stated. “The authors run lots of simulations using different thicknesses for all of the layers, and they seem to always get this bit of mantle sandwiched between the crust of the two plates.”
Douwe van Hinsbergena teacher of worldwide tectonics and paleogeography at Utrecht University in the Netherlands who wasn’t associated with the research study, disagreed that the outcomes are questionable. “It’s a nice new finding and an elegant interpretation,” he informed Live Science in an e-mail. “If a continent shoves below another continent, you’d expect a sandwich that consists from top to bottom of crust and mantle lithosphere of the upper (Tibet) plate, and then the crust of the lower (Indian) plate.”
Sascha is a U.K.-based personnel author at Live Science. She holds a bachelor’s degree in biology from the University of Southampton in England and a master’s degree in science interaction from Imperial College London. Her work has actually appeared in The Guardian and the health site Zoe. Composing, she delights in playing tennis, bread-making and searching pre-owned stores for covert gems.
Find out more
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
