As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

“We’ve seen increasingly restrictive rules on transgender participation in sport, often justified by claims of large and unavoidable physical advantages,” Gualano stated.

While distributing testosterone levels appear to increase muscle mass, strength and aerobic capability, these restrictions, usually focused on transgender females and ladies, typically argue that even previous direct exposure to testosterone throughout the age of puberty provides people an irreversible and fundamental physical benefit over cisgender females.

To see if that held true, the scientists pooled information from numerous research studies that utilized various techniques and steps to compare fitness in transgender and cisgender individuals. The research study individuals varied from 14 to 41 years of ages, and a lot of were grownups.

Amongst transgender ladies, hormonal agent treatments consisted of various kinds of estrogen and antiandrogens, which reduce the results of testosterone, while transgender guys utilized different types of testosterone. The majority of research studies followed individuals for about one to 3 years of treatment.

When stabilized for height, “transgender women, after gender-affirming hormone therapy, do not show greater strength or aerobic capacity than cisgender women,” Gualano stated. That consisted of both upper and lower-body strength.

The Milano Cortina 2026 Winter Olympic

video games are ranging from Feb. 6 to 22 this year.

(Image credit: Photo by Alex Pantling through Getty Images )Transgender females likewise had similar fat mass to that of cisgender females.

They have a little greater lean mass, he kept in mind, however that does not equate into higher strength or optimum oxygen intakeResearch studies seldom take a look at metrics of particular athletic efficiency, so the group might not evaluate that, Gualano included.

The majority of the research study individuals consisted of in the analysis were not competitive professional athletes, so “we should be cautious about extrapolating directly to elite sport,” Gualano kept in mind. That stated, “if there were large, intrinsic physical advantages, we would expect to observe them even in non-athletic populations, and we do not.”

“What’s new here is the consistency of these findings across many datasets,” Ada Cheungan endocrinologist and head of the Trans Health Research Group at the University of Melbourne, who was not associated with the research study, informed Live Science in an e-mail. The outcomes challenge the concept that trans females have intrinsic athletic benefits, she included.

Phoebe Toups Dugasan associate teacher of human-centered computing in the Exertion Games Lab at Monash University in Australia who was not associated with the research study, concurred.

“Counter to narratives being used to push transgender athletes out of sport, there’s no evidence that transgender women have any kind of advantage,” she informed Live Science in an e-mail. “There’s no reason to ban us from playing.”

Olympic competitorsWhile the U.S. Olympic Committee has prohibited transgender females from contending in ladies’s occasions to line up with an executive order from President Donald Trumpthe International Olympic Committee (IOC) has actually not yet done so. Current reporting recommends that may alteras the IOC has stated it will release brand-new guidelines this year. The IOC medical and clinical director has actually supposedly specified that, even after hormonal agent treatment, transgender females who have actually gone through male the age of puberty keep physical benefits over cisgender ladies. She has stated the brand-new guidelines likewise might use to cisgender females with “male” qualities, such as Y chromosomes or “male levels” of testosterone.

The outcomes of the current meta-analysis do not support those guidelines, Gualano stated. While the brand-new analysis can’t inform us anything about the physical fitness of cisgender females with fairly high testosterone, other datasets recommend that “performance is not determined by testosterone alone,” he included.

“A major gap in the literature is our limited understanding of how hormonal effects interact with long-term training and social context, particularly in women and gender diverse populations,” Gualano stated. “Another gap lies in the assumption that testosterone thresholds neatly separate ‘fair’ from ‘unfair’ competition, an idea that is far less scientifically robust than often assumed.”

In the meantime, the previous guidelines remain in location for the 2026 Winter Olympicswhich start Feb. 6 in Milan. Elis Lundholm of Sweden will contend in magnate snowboarding as the Winter Games’ Honestly transgender professional athleteAs this conversation unfolds, it’s crucial to keep in mind that couple of research studies track transgender professional athletes in high-stakes competitors, in part due to the fact that there are really couple of contending.Provided an absence of information on elite sports, an analysis like Gualano’s can be extremely helpful, Toups Dugas stated.

“These findings are of tremendous value to the IOC,” she stated. “There is a big opportunity here for the IOC to make the Olympics more diverse and really support athletes.”

Youth sportsThe majority of professional athletes, naturally, aren’t contending in the Olympics. Rather, lots of are kids playing youth sports. A minimum of 29 U.S. states presently prohibit transgender youth from completing on groups lined up with their gender identity, and although a few of these restrictions have actually been lawfully challenged, they are anticipated to be maintained by the U.S. Supreme Court in 2026.

The brand-new meta-analysis consisted of some information from teenagers, it was not adequate to make robust conclusions about kids’ body structure, Toups Dugas stated. “But I don’t think it needs to for us to make sensible choices.”

Cheung concurred. “There is no evidence here to justify categorical bans on trans youth in sport.”

This short article is for educational functions just and is not suggested to use medical guidance.

Sieczkowska, S. M., Mazzolani, B. C., Coimbra, D. R., Longobardi, I., Casale, A. R., Da Hora, J. D. F. V. M. P., Roschel, H., & & Gualano, B. (2026 ). Body structure and fitness in transgender versus cisgender people: a methodical evaluation with meta-analysis. British Journal of Sports Medicine https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2025-110239

Kristina Killgrove is a personnel author at Live Science with a concentrate on archaeology and paleoanthropology news. Her short articles have actually likewise appeared in places such as Forbes, Smithsonian, and Mental Floss. Kristina holds a Ph.D. in biological sociology and an M.A. in classical archaeology from the University of North Carolina, along with a B.A. in Latin from the University of Virginia, and she was previously a university teacher and scientist. She has actually gotten awards from the Society for American Archaeology and the American Anthropological Association for her science composing.

Find out more