Maybe a customer becomes aware of them in the remark area of the Facebook group “Medical Exemption Accepted,” or on the r/unvaccinated online forum on Reddit. Perhaps it’s through an interview published on the video-sharing platform Rumble. Or perhaps it’s the targeted ads on Google:” We do medical exemptions”

Cassandra Clerkin, a mom in upstate New York, very first contacted Frontline Health Advocates near the start of the 2024– 2025 academic year, after hearing they had physicians who would compose exemptions from school immunization requirements. Among Clerkin’s kids, she stated, had actually suffered seizures after getting a vaccine. The household didn’t desire more shots. New York has some of the nation’s strictest school immunization policies.

Possibly Frontline might assist.

Vaccine requireds have a long history in the United States, however they’ve gone through fresh spotlight– and partisan conflict– given that the start of the Covid-19 pandemic. Frontline Health Advocates relatively emerged from pandemic-era fights with a design that, specialists state, seems distinct: It costs itself as a standalone company that provides individuals throughout the United States with medical exemptions from vaccination requirements– for a charge of $495.

On types acquired by Undark, Frontline’s noted addresses are a storage center in Denison, Texas, and a plan shop in Sedona, Arizona. The group releases little details online about its management or financial resources, however it has actually silently established a following.

There’s little concern that Frontline exemptions often work, and some moms and dads report favorable experiences with the company. There are genuine concerns about whether its legal technique would hold up in court– and whether customers are puzzled about what, exactly, they are getting.

In upstate New York, Clerkin stated she consulted with an agent from Frontline by phone about the procedure. They made it sound, she stated, like getting an exemption “would be quite smooth.”

Right after, she remembered, she got a call from a medical professional called Andrew Zywiec. A week after the household released a charge card payment of $495 to a chiropractic company in California, the medical exemption shown up by e-mail. “The period of the limitation from getting VACCINATIONS is PERMANENT,” the file specified, mentioning a variety of health issues, and cautioning that civil or criminal charges might result if the school district neglected the demand.

Clerkin sent the file to the district.

Eextremely state in the nation has legal language on the books that appears to need specific immunizations before kids can register in school– although in some locations exemption policies are so lax that shots are efficiently optional. The armed force likewise has vaccine requirements, as do some civilian offices, consisting of numerous healthcare facilities and retirement home. Migration procedures, too, typically need candidates to get shots.

Some individuals might sign up individual objections to vaccination, or they might have medical conditions that might make getting a shot harmful. Workarounds exist. The majority of states, for instance, enable moms and dads to make an application for spiritual or individual belief exemptions from school vaccine requirements by mentioning that they challenge vaccination due to deeply held convictions. Those exemptions are often rejected, and in 4 states– California, Connecticut, Maine, and New York– they aren’t a choice at all. (The policy in a 5th state, West Virginia, is presently in flux.)

In those states, the only method to go to school without a needed shot is to get a medical waiver. There are genuine factors for some individuals to pursue them: They might be immunocompromised in a manner that makes sure vaccines high-risk, or they might have had a bad response to a shot in the past. Sometimes, households might earnestly think their kid can not securely get a vaccine, however have problem discovering a doctor who concurs, or who wants to vouch for that on an exemption.

Interest in medical exemptions tends to grow when laws tighten up. In 2015, after a measles break out at Disneyland sickened numerous individuals, California legislators ended the state’s individual belief exemption. Nearly instantly, the medical exemption rate more than doubled, according to a 2019 paper by a group of public health scientists. The law “developed a black market for medical exemptions,” one unnamed health officer informed the scientists. Moms and dads, the officer included, would browse the web and “get medical exemptions from doctors who were not their kid’s dealing with doctor.”

The state split down, prosecuting some healthcare service providers for apparently supplying incorrect medical exemptions, and tightening up the guidelines for getting a waiver. New york city, which got rid of spiritual exemptions in 2019, has actually taken comparable actions; the Department of Health keeps a public list of healthcare service providers who have actually been prohibited or suspended from utilizing immunization windows registries in the state, on a website entitled “School Vaccination Fraud Awareness.”

In New York, supporters state, specify policies have actually made it excessively challenging for some households to get medical exemptions, no matter the factor. “My understanding is that up till this year, once again, a great deal of medical professionals weren’t ready to compose these medical exemptions,” stated Chad Davenport, a lawyer outside Buffalo, New York, who typically represents households looking for medical exemptions.(One of his customers just recently won an essential judgment in a federal lawsuit versus a Long Island school district that had actually rejected medical exemptions from a minimum of 6 healthcare suppliers.)

Get In Frontline Health Advocates. The company, Davenport stated, “type of actioned in and supplied households a minimum of an alternative, or a prospective course.”

2 scientists who have actually studied vaccination exemptions in the United States stated the company appears to have a special design: While specific physicians have actually in some cases gotten a track record for providing medical exemptions, neither specialist had actually seen a full-fledged nationwide company providing those services.

“They’re really outright,” stated Dorit Reiss, a teacher at UC Law San Francisco who studies vaccine law and policy.

The group’s creator and director is William Lionberger, a chiropractic physician who has actually been accredited to practice in California given that 1981, and who as soon as kept a practice north of San Diego. According to public records, he has actually likewise acted as a policeman in a town near Sedona. (Lionberger decreased an ask for an on-the-record interview, and the company did not address a list of concerns from Undark.) Recruiters who have actually hosted Lionberger on their programs explain him as connected with America’s Frontline Doctors, a group that opposed Covid-19 vaccines and other public health procedures while promoting unverified treatments like hydroxychloroquine.

Frontline Health Advocates’ web page was very first signed up in March 2022, with a name echoing that of America’s Frontline Doctors. By April of that year, the site was welcoming visitors to “Get your exemption now.” In a 2023 interview, Lionberger explained having a “group of medical specialists” who “deal with all type of circumstances,” assessing customers both for “routine vax injuries and routine vax exemptive conditions.”

He included: “People now do not even desire their kids to get anywhere near a routine vaccine.”

The group uses a set of unique legal methods. Among these is to form itself as something called a Private Ministerial Association. Online, some groups that assist establish such personal associations explain them as providing unique First Amendment securities. A subscription application file hosted on Frontline’s site explains the group as “a personal, unincorporated ministry that runs as much as possible, outside the jurisdiction of federal government entities, firms, officers, representatives, professionals, and other agents, as safeguarded by law.”

Another method is to conjure up federal impairment law. In the 2023 interview, Lionberger boasted that they made use of “the most effective thing that you can bring versus discrimination”– particularly, federal securities. An advertising video published on the Frontline site makes a comparable claim, marketing waivers “supported by the securities under United States federal laws.” Undark got 3 near-identical exemptions sent out to New York households in 2024. In them, Frontline argues that the customer’s requirement for a medical exemption is safeguarded under the Americans with Disabilities Act, or ADA, which ensures specific lodgings for individuals with specials needs and other medical requirements.

In Frontline files from 2024, the company recommends that this federal security supersedes state vaccination laws– using a method around exemption policies throughout the nation.

In New York, Clerkin had actually gotten a file integrating medical language with legal information. The file bore the signatures of physician Andrew Zywiec and an administrative law expert and JD, Christine Pazzula, in addition to the seal of the United States Department of Justice.

Not whatever was rather as it appeared. Frontline has no relationship with the Department of Justice. Pazzula, according to her LinkedIn profile, had actually gotten her legal degree from an unaccredited correspondence school in California, and her name does not appear in databases of lawyers confessed to the bar in New York, Texas, or Nevada, where her LinkedIn profile states she is based. (In a quick e-mail to Undark, Pazzula stated she no longer works for Frontline.)

Another moms and dad who got a Frontline exemption in 2024 would later on affirm under oath that she thought Zywiec to be a doctor accredited in the state of New York, however state records reveal that no one called Zywiec has actually ever held a medical license in the state.

Numerous online reviews about Frontline discuss Zywiec. An evaluation of public records recommends a rough history. Zywiec served in the Army and finished from medical school in 2019, according to a CV. In 2020, he started a pediatrics residency at The Brooklyn Hospital Center, however the relationship soured: He eventually took legal action against the health center, declaring a risky workplace, and submitted a work problem that, to name a few issues, stated he had actually been “pushed into taking the so-called Covid-19 vaccine.” In court files connected with the suit, a medical facility authorities explained a staff member who was “spotty and hard.” In 2021, Zywiec’s co-residents had actually composed a letter to their superiors declaring that he had actually made offending remarks to associates and dealt with nurses inadequately, likewise composing that he “would postpone care to clients due to the fact that he wished to take part in treatments unassociated to his clients due to the fact that they intrigued him.”

Zywiec preserves an online medical practice, where he explains himself as “a worldwide medical physician and board-certified native medication company” and provides a variety of services, consisting of a $150, 30-minute, “Medical Excuse/Note” assessment that yields a “genuine medical reason customized to your circumstance.” On X, where he has actually accumulated a following in the 10s of thousands, Zywiec routinely shares content about the risks of vaccines.

The marketing video on Frontline’s site explains the exemptions as “signed by state-licensed doctors with complete qualifications.” Zywiec’s name does not appear in a nationwide database of certified doctors kept by the Federation of State Medical Boards. (In a short e-mail, Zywiec referred interview demands to Frontline. He did not respond to a list of concerns from Undark, and Frontline did not react to a concern about Zywiec’s license status.)

The exemption that Zywiec had actually signed for Clerkin was rejected. In a letter, the school district discussed that New York law needs exemptions to be signed by a doctor accredited in the state. Clerkin stated that she understood Zywiec was not accredited in New York, however Frontline appeared positive in their technique, and she believed it may work. That did not work out, she stated. “I seem like they talk this huge thing,” Clerkin stated. She included, “if you understand that you can’t assist these kids, and you’re simply preying on these moms who will do anything for their kids, that is wicked.”

Some Frontline exemptions do survive, a minimum of in New York. “I can definitely inform you that there have actually been some individuals, even this year, who have actually had the ability to get their Frontline Health waivers accepted,” Davenport informed Undark. He stated, courts have actually not checked the argument that an exemption conjuring up federal law will defeat the state’s requirement that the exemption comes from a New York-licensed doctor. He does not suggest Frontline to customers. “I generally inform them, although Frontline might technically be appropriate, it’s not an excellent legal position for you to be in,” Davenport stated. “And so I constantly encourage them to attempt to get a New York state waiver signed by a New York state medical professional and after that send that, since that puts you in the very best legal position.”

In a video on its site, Frontline cautions possible customers that exemptions might be rejected, keeping in mind that the group “can not ensure that an unidentified individual you are engaging with is going to follow federal laws.” Rita Palma, a health flexibility activist on Long Island who has actually worked with numerous households looking for medical exemptions, informed Undark that she believes moms and dads are still puzzled about the restrictions of the waivers. “What I’m receiving from moms and dads is that Frontline Health Advocates state that federal law bypasses state law,” she stated. Whether that’s real when it comes to vaccine exemptions stays uncertain.

The $495 cost– additional for expedited service– is a high rate for some households. “They’ve made a great killing in New York,” Palma stated. “I dislike to put it like that, however they’ve certainly gotten a great deal of moms and dads to pay them to get exemptions.”

It’s tough to understand the number of waivers Frontline has actually offered. In online forums, individuals explain successes with schools. “I got life time medical exemptions for my kids,” one moms and dad composed in a Facebook group in April, keeping in mind that she was not associated with Frontline. The group is “brimming with legal representatives to react to any pushback from schools,” she included.

One mom in Connecticut informed Undark that she had actually called Frontline in 2024, when her kid required an influenza shot to remain in day care. “I was taking a look around for a method to get an exemption,” she stated. (The mom spoke on condition of privacy, mentioning an expert requirement for personal privacy.) After a telephone call with a certified pediatrician in Texas, she got an exemption. The day care, she stated, accepted it. “It was a quite smooth experience, in general,” she stated.

“I understood that it was a gamble,” the mom stated; Frontline had actually informed her the exemption may not be accepted. “But then they type of resembled, well, you understand, technically, if they do not accept it, it’s unlawful since it’s safeguarded by ADA and all that example,” she stated.

68 Comments