FDA bans red dye No. 3 in food

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Red color No. 3 is no longer allowed food or oral drugs, per a choice from the U.S. FDA.
(Image credit: Elva Etienne through Getty Images)

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)will no longer permit red color No. 3 to be utilized in food, beverages or consumed drugs, like cough syrup, the firm revealed Wednesday (Jan. 15 ).

In its statement, the FDA pointed out the Delaney Clause — part of the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act– as the factor for its choice. This stipulation needs that the FDA restriction food and color ingredients that are discovered to trigger cancer in human beings or animals.

In this case, “or” is the personnel word because stipulation. In a number of research studies, red color No. 3 was connected to cancer in male laboratory rats, however these cancer-causing impacts have actually not been seen in other animals or in people, the FDA kept in mind.

Those rat research studies forced the FDA to prohibit the additive from cosmetics and topical drugs back in 1990, The Washington Post reported at the time. That choice had actually followed a petition that asked the FDA to check out these particular usages for the color. In the end, the firm likewise mentioned the Delaney Clause when eliminating the additive from cosmetics and topical drugs, and now, it has actually used the exact same reasoning to foods and consumed drugs.

Related: What is brominated grease, and why did the FDA restriction it in food?

Among the rat research studies included feeding 70 male rats really high dosages of red color No. 3, comparable to 4% of their diet plans over a life time. Fifteen of the rats established growths of the thyroid, a gland in the throat, however the majority of the growths were not malignant. Growths did disappoint up in male rats fed lower dosages of the color or in female rats fed any dosage. And when researchers did the experiment in mice, instead of rats, they didn’t see growths in males or women.

Later research studies recommended that the growths came from a particular hormone modification activated by the build-up of red color in male rats. That hormone system is just pertinent to rats, the Post reported.

Get the world’s most interesting discoveries provided directly to your inbox.

Simply put, “the way that FD&C Red No. 3 causes cancer in male rats does not occur in humans,” the FDA stressed in its statement. What’s more, “relevant exposure levels to FD&C Red No. 3 for humans are typically much lower than those that cause the effects shown in male rats.” The offered proof for that reason recommends that consuming red No. 3 does not put people at threat.

“it doesn’t matter, because the FDA mandate under the Delaney Clause says that if it shows cancer in animals or humans, they’re supposed to keep it from the food supply,” Jennifer Pomeranzan associate teacher of public health policy and management at New York University’s School of Global Public Health, informed CNN

The FDA has actually prohibited the color “as a matter of law,” its declaration states.

Red color no. 3, likewise referred to as erythrosine, offers items a brilliant, cherry-red color. The FDA kept in mind that the color is discovered in some sweets, cakes, cookies and frozen desserts, to name a few items, however that it’s not as typical as other food dyes.

Particular brand names of fruit mixed drinks, lollipop rings, beef sticks and sweet corn are amongst the foods which contain the color, according to a database assembled by the Environmental Working Group (EWG), a customer advocacy not-for-profit.

The EWG, which has a sis lobbying company called EWG Action Fund, was a singing supporter of the red color No. 3 restriction. In 2022, it and other companies petitioned the FDA to review the additive, asking the company to particularly think about the Delaney Clause. (The EWG has traditionally drawn some criticism for overemphasizing the risks of different chemicals in food and the environment.)

Any U.S. food makers who utilize red color No. 3 will have up until January 2027 to reformulate their items, while drug producers will have up until January 2028. Products imported into the nation likewise needs to adhere to the restriction.

Table of Contents

Disclaimer

This post is for informative functions just and is not suggested to use medical recommendations.

Nicoletta Lanese is the health channel editor at Live Science and was formerly a news editor and personnel author at the website. She holds a graduate certificate in science interaction from UC Santa Cruz and degrees in neuroscience and dance from the University of Florida. Her work has actually appeared in The Scientist, Science News, the Mercury News, Mongabay and Stanford Medicine Magazine, to name a few outlets. Based in NYC, she likewise stays greatly associated with dance and carries out in regional choreographers’ work.