Rather, Meta argued, offered proof “is clearly a sign” that the flagged adult material was torrented for “private individual usage”– given that the percentage connected to Meta IP addressess and staff members represented just “a couple of lots titles annually periodically acquired one file at a time.”

“The even more possible reasoning to be drawn from such weak, uncoordinated activity is that diverse people downloaded adult videos for individual usage,” Meta’s filing stated.

Unlike claims raised by book authors whose works are part of a massive dataset utilized to train AI, the activity on Meta’s business IP addresses just amounted to about 22 downloads per year. That is no place near the “collective effort to gather the enormous datasets Plaintiffs declare are essential for efficient AI training,” Meta argued.

Even more, that supposed activity can’t even dependably be connected to any Meta worker, Meta argued.

Strike 3 “does not determine any of the people who allegedly utilized these Meta IP addresses, declare that any were used by Meta or had any function in AI training at Meta, or define whether (and which) material apparently downloaded was utilized to train any specific Meta design,” Meta composed.

“10s of thousands of staff members,” as well as “numerous specialists, visitors, and 3rd celebrations access the Internet at Meta every day,” Meta argued. While it’s “possible one or more Meta workers” downloaded Strike 3’s material over the last 7 years, “it is simply as possible” that a “visitor, or freeloader,” or “specialist, or supplier, or repair work individual– or any mix of such individuals– was accountable for that activity,” Meta recommended.

Other supposed activity consisted of a claim that a Meta professional was directed to download adult material at his daddy’s home, however those downloads, too, “are clearly a sign of individual intake,” Meta argued. That professional worked as an “automation engineer,” Meta kept in mind, without any evident basis offered why he would be anticipated to source AI training information because function. “No truths plausibly” connect “Meta to those downloads,” Meta declared.