What if the Persians had defeated Alexander the Great?

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Alexander the Great developed his large empire in simply 13 years. What if the Persians had beat him?
(Image credit: Andreas Wolochow through Shutterstock)

Alexander the Great developed an empire that extended from the Balkans to India in simply 13 years, when he was king of Macedonia. His conquest began in Persia, where he fought King Darius III’s forces in what is now Turkey, Iraq, Iran and Egypt. After beating the Persian Empire he moved even more east, conquering land in what is now Afghanistan and Pakistan. After entering what is now India his soldiers mutinied. Alexander then reversed however ended up being ill and passed away all of a sudden in Babylonin what is now Iraq, in 323 B.C.

When his empire broke down after his unforeseen death, his authorities and generals took control of parts of itand Greek language and culture prospered throughout the Middle East for centuries.

What if Alexander had been beat by the Persians from the start? How would history have unfolded? Historic records show that this almost taken place. In the very first significant fight Alexander battled, at the Granicus River in Turkey, a Persian satrap(leader)called Spithridates almost landed a blow to Alexander’s head, Frank Holta teacher emeritus of ancient history at the University of Houston, informed Live Science in an e-mail.

What would have occurred if Alexander had stopped working and the Persians thrived?

Related: Why didn’t Alexander the Great get into Rome?

If Alexander the Great had actually been beat, we ‘d reside in an indistinguishable world

“In short, if the Persians defeated Alexander, the world might be unrecognizable,” Nikolaus Overtooman associate teacher of history at Washington State University who has actually studied and blogged about Alexander thoroughly, informed Live Science in an e-mail.

He kept in mind that Alexander’s conquests and the time duration later introduced the “Hellenistic” age. “This was a period of immense cultural, economic, and geopolitical exchange, change, and growth, where Greek civilization had a major influence on developing societies from Spain to India,” Overtoom stated.

Get the world’s most interesting discoveries provided directly to your inbox.

Individuals because area utilized a typical language referred to as Koine Greek, which ended up being the “lingua franca of the Hellenistic Age to facilitate the exchange of communication, commerce, and ideas,” Overtoom stated.

If Alexander had stopped working, would Christianity have spread out?

If Alexander had actually been beat, Christianity– which did not appear up until more than 3 centuries after Alexander’s death– might have passed away off before it might spread out extensively. “Koine Greek was the language used to write down and share the early teachings and thoughts of Christianity, and it was used to rapidly share the messages of Christianity across the Mediterranean and Middle East,” Overtoom stated.

“If there is no Hellenistic Age, then Koine Greek does not become the lingua franca of antiquity,” he stated. “If Koine Greek is not available to the early Christians because of this, then they have to use a less effective and well-known language for their writings and preaching, and if that is the case, then Christianity is not nearly as successful and perhaps does not become a world religion.” It might not have actually even made it through in an extremely competitive intellectual and spiritual area in the very first to 4th centuries, he included.

Other scholars concurred that Christianity might not have actually ended up being as extensive, and Larry Tritlea teacher emeritus of history at Loyola Marymount University, stated that Christianity might not have actually endured up until present day if the Persians had actually beat Alexander.

The Persians might have beat Alexander the Great in various fights throughout his conquest. How might that have altered history? (Image credit: Ella_Ca through Shutterstock )

Numerous other modifications

History would have altered in myriad other methods if Alexander had actually been beat by the Persians. “A ‘Pax Persica’ [Persian Peace] renowned for its tolerance” likely would have dominated from the borders of Greece to India,” Holt said, as Persia would have continued to control much of the Middle East with people free to practice their own religions and cultural customs. The Persian Empire’s capital, Persepolis, which Alexander’s forces captured and razed, “would measure up to Rome and Athens as the best of ancient cities, its ruins among the marvels most checked out today by wide-eyed travelers,” Holt added.

“There would have been no scattering of Greek inhabitants into cities throughout the east– no Alexandria in Egypt, no Kandahar, and so on,” Holt said. “The so-called Hellenistic world, that remarkable amalgam of histories and cultures, might not be produced without these brand-new settlements drawing the Greeks ever eastward in droves.”

The Ptolemies, who led a dynasty in Egypt that lasted nearly three centuries, would never have taken over Egypt, and Cleopatra VII would not have been a famous queen, according to Holt.

Table of Contents

What if Alexander the Great had been defeated by the Persians — but a bit later

If Alexander were defeated by the Persians at the Battle of Gaugamela, which took place in northern Iraq in 331 B.C., then history would still be dramatically, but not completely, altered, Holt noted. By then, Alexander had taken Egypt and founded Alexandria, and this city may have still thrived, he said.

If the defeat had come later still — such as when Alexander was fighting against Bessus, who became the self-proclaimed Persian king after Darius III was killed — then history would also have been different.

“Could Bessus have reconstructed Persepolis or restored control of Egypt and the Levant?” Holt wondered. The Levant is a land in the eastern Mediterranean and includes what is today Israel and Lebanon as well as parts of Syria, Jordan and other nearby areas.

It’s also possible that a defeat by Bessus could have caused political power in the Middle East to become more fragmented than it did. If the region had remained divided, Rome might have taken advantage of that weakness both before and after it became an empire in 27 B.C. “The fragmentation of Eurasia might have sped up the royal growth of Rome beyond our picturing,” Holt said. “Can you visualize Nero on an elephant in India?”

Owen Jarus is a routine factor to Live Science who discusses archaeology and people’past. He has actually likewise composed for The Independent (UK), The Canadian Press(CP )and The Associated Press(AP), to name a few. Owen has a bachelor of arts degree from the University of Toronto and a journalism degree from Ryerson University.