Over the last month there has actually been something more than a small kerfuffle in the area market over the return of 2 NASA astronauts from the International Space Station.

The fate of Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams, who introduced on the very first crewed flight of Boeing’s Starliner spacecraft on June 5, 2024, has actually ended up being a political problem after President Donald Trump and SpaceX creator Elon Musk stated the astronauts’ return was held up by the Biden White House.

In February, Trump and Musk appeared on FOX News. Throughout the joint interview, the topic of Wilmore and Williams showed up. They stay in area today after NASA chose it would be finest they did not fly home in their malfunctioning Starliner spacecraft– however would return in a SpaceX-built Crew Dragon.

“At the President’s request, or instruction, we are accelerating the return of the astronauts, which was postponed to a ridiculous degree,” Musk stated.

“They got left in space,” Trump included.

“They were left up there for political reasons, which is not good,” Musk concluded.

After this interview, a Danish astronaut called Andreas Mogensen asserted that Musk was lying. “What a lie,” Mogensen composed on the social networks website Musk owns, X. “And from someone who complains about lack of honesty from the mainstream media.”

Musk provided a caustic action to Mogensen. “You are fully retarded,” Musk composed. “SpaceX could have brought them back several months ago. I OFFERED THIS DIRECTLY to the Biden administration and they refused. Return WAS pushed back for political reasons. Idiot.”

What’s the fact?

NASA has actually not straight responded to concerns about this over the last month. The individuals who truly understand the response lie within the human spaceflight programs at the area company. After one press conference was canceled last month, 2 crucial NASA authorities were lastly offered on a media teleconference on Friday night. These were Ken Bowersox, associate administrator, Space Operations Mission Directorate, and Steve Stich, supervisor, of NASA’s Commercial Crew Program, which is accountable for Starliner and Crew Dragon flights.

Musk is basically making 2 claims. He is stating that last year SpaceX used to bring Wilmore and Williams home from the International Space Station– and made the deal straight to the Biden Administration. And the deal was declined for “political” factors.

Second, Musk states that, at Trump’s demand, the return of Wilmore and Williams was sped up. The set is now most likely to return home to Earth as part of the Crew 9 objective later on this month, about a week after the launch of a brand-new group of astronauts to the spaceport station. This Crew 10 objective has a launch date of March 12, so Wilmore and Williams might lastly fly home about 2 weeks from now.

Let’s analyze each of Musk’s claims because of what Bowersox and Stich stated Friday night.

Was Musk’s deal decreased for political factors?

On July 14, in 2015, NASA granted SpaceX an unique agreement to study numerous choices to bring Wilmore and Williams home on a Crew Dragon automobile. At the time, the area company was thinking about alternatives if Starliner was identified to be risky. Amongst the choices NASA was thinking about were to fly Wilmore and Williams home on the Crew 8 automobile connected to the station (which would put an unmatched 6 individuals in the pill) or asking SpaceX to autonomously fly a Dragon to the station to return Wilmore and Williams individually.

“The SpaceX folks helped us with a lot of options for how we would bring Butch and Suni home on Dragon in a contingency,” Bowersox stated throughout Friday’s teleconference. “When it comes to adding on missions, or bringing a capsule home early, those were always options. But we ruled them out pretty quickly just based on how much money we’ve got in our budget, and the importance of keeping crews on the International Space Station. They’re an important part of maintaining the station.”

As an outcome, the Crew 9 objective released in September with simply 2 astronauts. Wilmore and Williams signed up with that team for a complete, six-month increment on the spaceport station.

Stich stated NASA made that choice based upon flight schedules to the spaceport station and the orbiting lab’s requirements. It likewise enabled time to send out SpaceX spacesuits up for the set of astronauts and to produce seat liners that would make their landing in the water, under parachutes, safe.

“When we laid all that out, the best option was really the one that we’re embarking upon now,” Stich stated. “And so we did Crew 9, flying the two empty seats, flying a suit for Butch up, and also making sure that the seats were right for Butch’s anthropometrics, and Suni’s, to return them safely.”

Yes, SpaceX has actually been working with NASA to provide choices, consisting of the possibility of a return last fall. Those conversations were being held within the program levels and their leaders: Stich for Commercial Crew and Dana Weigel for the International Space Station.

“Dana and I worked to come up with a decision that worked for the Commercial Crew Program and Space Station,” Stich stated. “And then, Ken (Bowersox), we all we had the Flight Readiness Review process with you, and the Administrator of NASA listened in as well. So we had a recommendation to the agency and that was on the process that we typically use.”

Bowersox validated that the choice was made at the programmatic level.

“That’s typically the way our decisions work,” Bowersox stated. “The programs work what makes the most sense for them, programmatically, technically. We’ll weigh in at the headquarters level, and in this case we thought the plan that we came up with made a lot of sense.”

Throughout the teleconference, a vice president at SpaceX, Bill Gerstenmaier, was asked straight what provide Musk was describing when he discussed the Biden administration. He did not supply a substantive response.

187 Comments